Straightening Things Out with Clear Aligners vs Traditional Braces

Straightening Things Out with Clear Aligners vs Traditional Braces By Dr. Jon ( Junyi ) Ho | March 17, 2024

Starting orthodontic treatment for a straighter, more confident smile is a major decision. This is especially true when you’re weighing up between clear aligners vs traditional braces. It’s a big decision, right? You’re not just choosing how you’ll look for the next few months or even years, but also how you’ll live day-to-day.

Clear aligners have been all the rage lately, offering a subtle look and a convenient ride to straight teeth. They’re like the cool new kid on the block in the world of orthodontics. But then, there’s the tried-and-true conventional braces—those metal oral appliances that have been straightening smiles for ages. They’ve got a track record that’s hard to ignore.

Every individual’s journey to straighter teeth is unique. Understanding the key differences between clear aligners and traditional metal braces is crucial to making a decision. In this article, we will explore the various aspects of these teeth straightening options. We will consider not only the aesthetic outcomes but also the lifestyle implications, treatment duration, and overall effectiveness of each method.

Whether you’re drawn to the discreet charm of aligners or you prefer traditional metal braces, we’re here to assist. This friendly guide aims to help you figure out what feels right for you. Let’s dive in and straighten things out, shall we?

Summary of the Content:

  • Choosing between clear aligners vs metal braces involves considering aesthetics, comfort, and specific dental needs.
  • Clear aligners provide a discreet treatment option, while conventional braces offer a reliable option for complex orthodontic cases.
  • Being virtually invisible, comfortable, and allowing for easy maintenance of oral hygiene are some of the benefits of clear aligners.
  • However, clear aligners have a higher cost, require discipline for effective treatment, and may not be suitable for complex cases.
  • The advantages of traditional braces include their effectiveness for complex orthodontic issues, versatility, and often affordability.
  • However, traditional braces are visible, can cause discomfort, and come with dietary restrictions and oral hygiene challenges.
  • The choice between clear aligners and traditional braces depends on individual preferences, lifestyles, and specific orthodontic needs.
  • Consulting with a dentist is essential to determining a suitable option based on the severity of dental alignment issues and desired outcomes.

The Battle of Orthodontic Options

Exploring further into the clear aligners vs traditional braces debate, it’s essential to recognise that the choice you make will influence more than just your oral health. It will shape your daily experiences and interactions. The significance of selecting the right orthodontic treatment cannot be overstated. It’s a decision that intertwines with your identity, comfort, and even your social life.

  • Clear Aligners
    Teeth straightening options have broadened, offering more personalised options to meet diverse needs and preferences. Clear aligners, the modern alternative in orthodontic technology, represent a leap forward. They provide an option that blends seamlessly with the demands of modern life. The benefits of clear aligners extend beyond the aesthetic. They support the desire for a treatment that accommodates an active, busy lifestyle without the constant reminder of undergoing orthodontic treatment.
  • Traditional Braces

    Then there’s the classic route: traditional braces. The advantages of traditional braces go beyond their capability to manage complex orthodontic issues. They offer a sense of reliability grounded in decades of successful outcomes and orthodontic advancements. Each wire and bracket is a step closer to your goal, and for many, there’s something incredibly rewarding about that visible progress.

The battle between these orthodontic options is not just about choosing a tool for teeth straightening. It’s about aligning your entire treatment with your life goals, values, and how you see yourself during and after the process. This decision merits careful consideration of the benefits of clear aligners and the advantages of traditional braces. This way, your chosen path not only results in a beautiful smile but also complements your transition towards it.

Traditional Braces as The Classic Approach

Darch Dental Centre

Traditional braces have a long-standing history of transforming smiles by managing misaligned teeth and jaws. This classic approach to straightening teeth has evolved significantly from its early inception, yet its core principle remains the same: to apply continuous pressure over time, gently moving teeth into their desired positions.

  • A Glimpse into History
    The history of orthodontic braces dates back to ancient times. Archaeological evidence suggests that even ancient civilisations attempted to address dental irregularities using rudimentary forms of teeth braces. However, it wasn’t until the 18th century that significant advancements were made. This is thanks to pioneers like Pierre Fauchard, often referred to as the “Father of Modern Dentistry.” Fauchard’s innovative use of a “Bandeau,” a horseshoe-shaped device, marked a pivotal moment in the history of orthodontics. It laid the groundwork for today’s traditional braces. The “Bandeau” was designed to address tooth alignment by applying gentle pressure to the teeth, a principle that remains at the core of orthodontic treatment today.

    Fauchard’s pioneering work opened the doors to a new world of possibilities in dental care. Successing dental practitioners refined and expanded upon his treatment methods and tools, setting the stage for the sophisticated systems used in modern orthodontics. The “Bandeau” was the precursor to the metal brackets and archwires that characterise traditional braces today. This illustrates a direct lineage from Fauchard’s original designs to contemporary orthodontic appliances.
  • How They Work
    Constructed from high-grade stainless steel, traditional braces consist of metal brackets that are individually bonded to each tooth. These tooth brackets serve as anchors for the archwire, a thin metal wire that exerts pressure on the teeth. Tiny elastic bands, known as ligatures or O-rings, hold the archwire to the brackets, allowing for controlled movement of the teeth. Over time, the dentist adjusts the tension of the archwire, gradually guiding the teeth into alignment.


Traditional braces work by capitalising on the body’s natural ability to remodel its bone structure. The consistent pressure applied by the braces causes the bone around the teeth to break down and rebuild. This allows the teeth to move and eventually stabilise in their new positions. This process, known as bone remodelling, is fundamental to the success of traditional braces and all forms of orthodontic treatment.

Clear Aligners as the Modern Alternative

Clear aligners, such as Invisalign, have transformed orthodontic treatment, offering a discreet and innovative approach to straightening teeth. Unlike conventional braces, clear aligners are virtually invisible. This makes them an attractive option for teens and adults alike who are concerned about the aesthetic impact of orthodontic treatment.

How They Work

Clear aligners operate on a principle that might seem simple at first glance. However, it involves a complex interplay of biomechanics and material science.

  • Progressive Alignment:
    The treatment involves a series of aligners, each representing a step towards the final alignment goal. The aligners exert controlled force on specific teeth that need to be moved. This force is gentle yet effective, gradually shifting the teeth into their new positions.
  • Biomechanical Principles:
    The aligners leverage the biomechanical principle of applying continuous, gentle pressure to move teeth. This pressure stimulates the bone surrounding the tooth to remodel, allowing the tooth to move. The aligners are designed to move teeth horizontally and vertically and even rotate them when necessary.
  • Sequential Use:
    Patients transition to a new set of aligners every two weeks, on average. Each set is engineered to move the teeth incrementally, building on the progress made by the previous set. This approach allows for the movement to be gradual, minimising discomfort and optimising the treatment’s effectiveness.
  • Material Science:
    The aligners are made from a special type of medical-grade thermoplastic polymer, which is both strong and flexible. This material allows for efficient tooth movement while maintaining a high level of comfort for the patient.


The Innovative Approach

The innovative approach of clear aligners is transforming the field of orthodontics. It offers a blend of technology and customisation that caters to the modern patient’s needs.

  • Digital Planning:
    Treatment with clear aligners begins with a digital scan of the patient’s mouth, which eliminates the need for traditional dental impressions. This digital blueprint facilitates the creation of a detailed treatment strategy, visualising the gradual transformation of the patient’s dental alignment.
  • Customisation:
    Each aligner is tailor-made to fit the unique contours of the patient’s teeth for both comfort and efficacy. This customisation is crucial because it allows the aligners to apply pressure to the teeth in a precise and controlled manner.
  • Removability:
    A standout feature of clear aligners is their removability. This allows patients to remove their aligners for eating, brushing, and flossing, aiding in the maintenance of optimal oral hygiene throughout the treatment.
  • Predictability:
    Advanced software aids dentists in forecasting tooth movement and the anticipated treatment outcome, offering patients a preview of their future smiles.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Traditional Braces and Clear Aligners

When deciding between clear aligners and traditional braces for orthodontic treatment, it’s essential to weigh several key factors carefully. These considerations are important so that the chosen method aligns with your lifestyle, personal preferences, and specific dental needs. Understanding these factors is crucial for a successful and satisfying orthodontic treatment.

  • Personal Lifestyle and Preferences
    Your daily routine, work environment, and social engagements can significantly influence your choice. If aesthetics and discretion are priorities due to professional or personal reasons, clear aligners might be more appealing due to their virtually invisible nature. On the other hand, if you’re less concerned about visibility and more focused on the result, traditional braces might be a suitable option.
  • Treatment Goals and Dental Needs
    During your dental assessment appointment, discuss your goals with your dentist. The complexity and nature of your orthodontic issues are critical in determining a suitable and effective treatment. Clear aligners are often recommended for mild to moderate alignment and spacing issues. On the other hand, traditional braces are better suited for more complex cases involving significant bite management and tooth movements.
  • Comfort and Convenience
    Consider your tolerance for discomfort and your ability to adhere to treatment requirements. Clear aligners are known for their comfort and the convenience of being removable, which is beneficial for eating and oral hygiene. However, this removability requires strict discipline to wear the clear aligners for the recommended duration each day. Traditional braces, while fixed and sometimes less comfortable initially, eliminate the need for such discipline.
  • Oral Hygiene Practices
    Maintaining oral hygiene is important during orthodontic treatment. Evaluate your willingness and ability to commit to the cleaning regimen required by each option. Clear aligners allow for easier brushing and flossing due to their removability. Traditional braces may necessitate more time and special tools to maintain proper oral hygiene.
  • Financial Considerations
    The cost consideration of orthodontic treatment can vary widely between clear aligners and traditional braces. It’s important to consider not only the initial cost but also any potential additional expenses that may arise during the treatment. Additional expenses may include replacement aligners or unforeseen adjustments with braces.
  • Time Commitment
    The duration of treatment and the frequency of orthodontic visits can impact your decision. While both treatments generally require a similar overall time commitment, the nature of that commitment—such as the frequency of clinic visits—can differ.
  • Long-term Outcomes and Predictability

    Consider the track record and predictability of the treatment outcomes associated with each option. Discuss with your dentist the likelihood of achieving your desired results with clear aligners vs braces based on similar cases to yours.

Choosing between clear aligners and traditional braces involves a thorough evaluation of these factors. It’s important to have an open and detailed discussion with your dentist, who can provide guidance tailored to your unique situation. Ultimately, the right choice addresses your dental needs effectively, fits seamlessly into your lifestyle, and meets your personal preferences.

A Head-to-Head Comparison

A side-by-side comparison can be incredibly helpful when deciding about your orthodontic care. Below is a detailed comparison table summarising the key differences between clear aligners and regular metal braces.

FactorsClear AlignersTraditional Braces
AppearanceVirtually invisible, made of clear plastic.Visible, made of metal; coloured bands available.
Cost$6,000 to $9,000Around $8,000
Average Treatment Time12-18 months2 to 4 years
EffectivenessEffective for mild to moderate teeth alignment issues; may not be suitable for complex cases.Effective for a wide range of orthodontic issues, including complex cases.
ComfortSmooth edges with no metal parts, reducing irritation.Wires and brackets can cause temporary discomfort and irritation.
MaintenanceRemovable for easy cleaning, but requires discipline to wear 20-22 hours per day.Requires meticulous cleaning around brackets and wires.
Diet RestrictionsNone; aligners are removed while eating.Certain hard, chewy, and sticky foods must be avoided.
Follow-up VisitsLess frequent check-ups, as multiple aligner sets are provided in advance.Regular monthly visits for adjustments are required.
Treatment PlanningDigital scanning and 3D modelling provide a preview of the expected outcome.Traditional impressions are used; outcome visualisations are not as readily available.

Both clear aligners and traditional braces have advantages and disadvantages. While clear aligners offer better aesthetics and comfort, traditional braces are often more effective for complex orthodontic issues.

Both options have merits and drawbacks. Your choice will depend on various factors, including the complexity of your orthodontic needs, your lifestyle, and your budget.

Pros and Cons of Braces

When considering traditional braces, weighing the distinct benefits and drawbacks is crucial. Here’s a breakdown:

Pros

  • Effectiveness:
    Traditional braces are effective in addressing complex dental issues, including severe misalignment issues, overcrowding, and bite problems. Their sturdy nature allows for significant tooth movement and precise control over the alignment process.
  • Versatility:
    One of the advantages of braces is that they can address a diverse range of orthodontic issues. This makes them a versatile option for patients with complicated treatment requirements that clear aligners might not be able to address.
  • Customisation:
    Braces come with options for customisation, such as coloured bands. This allows patients, especially younger ones, to personalise their appearance and make the treatment experience more enjoyable.
  • Durability:
    Traditional braces are made of high-grade materials like stainless steel and are designed to withstand the rigours of treatment. This reduces the likelihood of breakage or damage.
  • Cost:
    In some cases, the cost of braces can be more affordable than clear aligners. They can be a more accessible option for a broader range of dental patients.


Cons

  • Aesthetics:
    The visibility of metal brackets and wires is often cited as a drawback. This is especially true for adults and teens who are concerned about the appearance of their smiles during treatment.
  • Discomfort:
    The brackets and wires can irritate the inside of the mouth, especially immediately after they are fitted or adjusted.
  • Dietary Restrictions:
    Patients with braces need to avoid certain types of food that are hard, sticky, or chewy to prevent damage to the braces. This can be a significant lifestyle adjustment.
  • Oral Hygiene Challenges:
    Maintaining oral hygiene with braces requires more effort. The traditional metal brackets and wires can trap food particles and make brushing and flossing more challenging. This increases the risk of plaque buildup and tooth decay.
  • Treatment Duration:
    While the duration of treatment with braces varies, it can sometimes be longer than with clear aligners. However, it depends on the complexity of the orthodontic issues being addressed.
  • Frequent Adjustments:
    One disadvantage of braces is the time they require. Traditional braces require regular visits to the dentist for adjustment appointments, which can be inconvenient for some people.


Traditional braces offer a highly effective and versatile treatment option for addressing a wide range of orthodontic issues. However, the decision to opt for braces should consider the aesthetic concerns, potential discomfort, and maintenance requirements associated with this treatment option. Discussing these factors with a dentist can help in making a choice that aligns with one’s lifestyle, preferences, and treatment goals.

Pros and Cons of Clear Aligners

Clear aligners also come with their own set of benefits and drawbacks that are worth considering:

Pros

  • Aesthetics:
    One of the appealing aspects of clear aligners, also called invisible braces, is their near-invisibility. It makes them a popular choice for teens and adult patients who are self-conscious about the appearance of traditional metal braces.
  • Comfort:
    Clear aligners are made from smooth plastic and are custom-fitted. This reduces the risk of irritation to the cheeks and gums often associated with the metal brackets and wires of traditional metal braces.
  • Removability:
    Clear aligners can be removed for eating, brushing, and flossing. This allows for better dental hygiene during treatment and no dietary restrictions, which is a significant advantage over fixed braces.
  • Predictable Results:
    Advanced 3D imaging technology allows for precise treatment planning and visualisation of the expected outcome before the treatment even begins. The technology provides a clear roadmap for orthodontic treatment.
  • Fewer Dental Visits:
    Clear aligners generally require fewer check-ups and adjustments than traditional braces, saving time and offering more convenience for busy individuals.


Cons

  • Discipline Required:
    The success of treatment with clear aligners heavily relies on the patient’s commitment to wearing them for the recommended 20-22 hours a day. Lack of discipline can result in extended orthodontic treatment times or less effective results.
  • Cost:
    Clear aligners can cost more than traditional braces, primarily due to the custom manufacturing process. The cost of treatment may vary depending on the complexity of the case and the duration of the treatment.
  • Not Suitable for All Cases:
    While technology has advanced, clear aligners may not be suitable for more complex issues that require significant tooth movement or rotation.
  • Potential for Loss or Damage:
    Since aligners are removable, there’s a risk of them being lost or damaged. This can result in delays in dental treatment and additional costs.
  • Temporary Discomfort:
    Each new set of aligners may cause temporary pressure and discomfort as the teeth begin to move. This is similar to the sensation experienced with traditional braces after adjustments.
  • Attachments:
    In some cases, clear aligners require attachments or buttons bonded to the teeth to aid in movement. They can slightly detract from the ‘invisible’ look.


Clear aligners offer a discreet, comfortable, and convenient orthodontic treatment option, particularly appealing to those looking to maintain a natural appearance. However, their effectiveness is contingent upon patient compliance, and they may not be suitable for all orthodontic conditions. Discussing these pros and cons with a dentist can help determine if clear aligners are the right choice for your specific needs and lifestyle.

Choosing What's Right for You

The journey to a beautiful smile is personal, and the orthodontic treatment you choose should align with your unique needs and lifestyle. Here are some guiding principles to help you decide between traditional braces and clear aligners:

Severity of Orthodontic Issue

  • Traditional Braces:
    Recommended for complex treatment cases, including severe misalignment, underbites, and overbites.
  • Clear Aligners:
    Suitable for moderate orthodontic issues.


Lifestyle and Preferences

  • Traditional Braces:
    A good option for those who prefer a hands-off approach to treatment.
  • Clear Aligners:
    Suitable for those who desire more control and flexibility in their customised treatment plan.


Budget Considerations

  • Traditional Braces:
    Generally more affordable.
  • Clear Aligners:
    Prices range from $6,000 to $9,000 for extensive orthodontic needs.


Consultation with Your Dentist

  • Initial Consultation:
    This is a crucial step in determining the appropriate treatment for your condition.
  • Treatment Plan:
    Your dentist will provide a tailored treatment plan based on individual orthodontic needs and preferences.


Choosing between traditional dental braces and clear plastic aligners is not a one-size-fits-all decision. It involves many factors, from the complexity of your orthodontic issues to your lifestyle and budget. A consultation with your dentist will offer valuable insights, advice, and a personalised treatment plan to guide you in making a decision.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between clear aligners vs traditional braces can be a difficult decision that can impact your smile and overall well-being. As we’ve explored, both teeth straightening options have benefits and drawbacks. The benefits of clear aligners often lie in their aesthetic appeal and comfort. On the other hand, the advantages of traditional braces are generally in their effectiveness for more complex orthodontic issues.

It’s crucial to consult with a qualified dentist to discuss your needs and develop a tailored treatment plan. At Darch Dental Centre, we’re committed to helping you make a decision that aligns with your lifestyle, budget, and orthodontic needs.

If you’re ready to take the next step to a beautiful, aligned smile, we invite you to book an appointment through our website or call our team. Your straighter, more beautiful smile is just a consultation away.

Dr. Jon ( Junyi ) Ho

Dr. Jon is a Perth-based dentist who graduated with a Bachelor of Dental Science in 2005 from the University of Western Australia. He has worked at a range of dental practices, including being a partner and principal dentist for a group of five dental surgeries in Sydney. Dr. Jon has been practising for over a decade in the northern suburbs of Perth. He provides treatment for patients in Darch, Madeley, Landsdale, Kingsway, Kingsley, Marangaroo, Alexander Heights, Wangara, Ellenbrook, and others.

Related Blogs

Choosing the Right Clear Aligner Material for Safety and Durability

Among orthodontic treatments, clear aligners represent a significant advancement, offering an aesthetic and less invasive alternative to traditional braces. However, the effectiveness and comfort of these aligners heavily depend on the material they are made from. Different materials can greatly influence the safety, durability, and overall treatment experience, making the...

Exploring the Aesthetic Benefits of Clear Aligners

When deciding on orthodontic treatment, the aesthetic aspect of the chosen treatment is an important consideration. The debate between clear aligners vs traditional braces focuses on balancing effective treatment with minimal visual disruption. Many patients now prioritise not just the outcome but also the treatment process, seeking methods that align...

The Remarkable Benefits of Clear Aligners

Many people view clear aligners as a simple path to straighter teeth, focusing primarily on the cosmetic benefits they offer. However, this perspective overlooks the comprehensive advantages that extend beyond mere aesthetics and affect oral health and lifestyle. This gap in understanding diminishes the perceived value of clear aligners in...